Platformonomics

Platformonomics
« Mind the Bathwater | Main | From Browse to Search to ... »

The Power of Ecosystems

Thursday, July 28, 2005

A nice piece in Fast Company by John Sviokla on the power of ecosystems.

The interesting question is whether you can plausibly make the transition from a closed/vertical industry model to an ecosystem/horizontal industry model.  It is hard to think of examples of companies successfully making that transition (got any candidates?).

The revenue hit when you move from owning the whole pie to accepting a smaller part of what you expect to be a much bigger pie is not a leap many companies are willing or able to make.  This is especially true of hardware companies trying to become software companies because the existing hardware revenue you give up (or at least put at risk) typically dwarfs the available software revenue in the short and even medium term.  It is also true of companies trying to move from low volume, high cost models to high volume, low cost models.  The problem is to get to high volume, low cost, there is usually a low volume, low cost waypoint. The radical change in cost structure required is just too painful for most companies to contemplate.

Comments [2]

Friday, July 29, 2005 2:07:08 AM (Pacific Daylight Time, UTC-07:00)
i can only think of one - your favourite company... IBM.

and now its reintegrating.

more interesting - has anyone gone from horizontal to vertical successfully?
Monday, August 08, 2005 10:06:49 AM (Pacific Daylight Time, UTC-07:00)
James,

While IBM would like you to believe they have made the transition from the paragon of vertically integrated computer companies to some more nimble, ecosystem-based company, there are two problems:

1.) IBM is still fundamentally dependent on the vertically integrated mainframe business. It is upwards of half their overall profit and for the software business, about two-thirds of their revenue comes from mainframe software annuities and undoubtedly an even higher percentage of profit. This is why IBM doesn't break out any numbers for their software business other than to hype relative growth for the more modern albeit still very small businesses.
2.) It isn't clear to me what ecosystem they have formed. Their ISV strategy is challenged as PeopleSoft disappearing illustrates.

But perhaps you are thinking of something else?

-- Charles
Name
E-mail
Home page

Comment (HTML not allowed)  

Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

Live Comment Preview